De Mille, Richard

De Mille, Richard – De Mille became suspicious that elements of Carlos Castaneda’s Yaqui “ethnography,” and indeed the shamaninformant Don Juan himself, were inauthentic—an elaborate fiction. He wrote a lengthy volume entitled Castaneda’s Journey: The Power and the Allegory (1976) assessing the veracity of Castaneda’s work in meticulous detail, with the follow-up work, The Don Juan Papers: Further Castaneda Controversies (1980) presenting arguments from both camps. De Mille pointed to the unavailability of Castaneda’s field notes due to their mysterious accidental loss or destruction, as well as to inconsistencies in dates, locations, and so on. In one specific example of plagiarism, the “waterfall jumping” of Don Juan’s fellow sorcerer Don Genaro replicates Barbara Myerhoff’s experience of watching the Huichol shaman Ramón Medina Silva perform this feat. Supporters of Castaneda point to the “validity” of the Don Juan mythos in speaking “truths” that stand outside ethnographic fact, whether the original ethnography was invented or not. Nonetheless, de Mille, Daniel Noel, and Yaqui representatives have conclusively debunked Castaneda.

SOURCE:

Historical Dictionary of Shamanism by Graham Harvey and Robert J. Wallis 2007

BOOKS FOR YOU TO READ IN OUR LIBRARY:

Related Articles

Don Juan

Don Juan – An alleged Yaqui sorcerer and informant to Carlos Castaneda and the central character in his prolific series of Don Juan books, including…

Silva, Ramón Medina

Silva, Ramón Medina (193?–1971) – Huichol (Wixáritari) shaman (mara’akame) and artist whose narrative yarn paintings depicting peyote visions were made famous by anthropologist Peter Furst.…

Yaqui

Yaqui – Calling themselves Yoeme (“people”), the more widely known term Yaqui derives from “Hiakim,” the Yaqui term for their land, encompassing the southern coastal…